How are records made and scored?
Each record holds facts a vendor publishes on its own pages. Every fact carries the page it came from, the date that page was read, and a status.
What do the statuses mean?
| vendor-stated | The vendor says so on the cited page. |
| verified | Confirmed against a second source or by use. |
| corrected | An earlier value was wrong and has been corrected. The change log shows both. |
| unavailable | The source has not been read or could not be read. Shown as pending. |
| assessed | The owner's judgement after testing the product. |
What does the Record Score measure?
Measures what the vendor publishes and what reviewers say. It does not measure quality.
The score adds points for each item the vendor publishes. An item whose source has not been read is pending: it is left out of the total and never counted as zero. A source that was read and did not contain the item scores zero for that item. The score is therefore shown as points earned out of points assessed.
Which items are scored?
Accounting
| Component | Item | Points |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing published | Price in rand on the vendor site | 5 |
| Pricing published | Plan limits stated | 5 |
| Pricing published | Add-on prices stated | 5 |
| Pricing published | VAT treatment of prices stated | 5 |
| Pricing published | Trial or free-tier terms stated | 5 |
| South African compliance support published | VAT201 return support | 10 |
| South African compliance support published | POPIA or data-protection statement | 8 |
| South African compliance support published | Data storage location stated | 7 |
| Bank feeds and integrations published | South African bank feeds listed | 8 |
| Bank feeds and integrations published | Public integrations directory | 7 |
| Terms published | Cancellation terms and notice period | 4 |
| Terms published | Data export on exit described | 4 |
| Terms published | Price-change notice period | 3 |
| Terms published | Support channels and hours | 4 |
| Help and onboarding published | Public help centre | 4 |
| Help and onboarding published | South Africa-specific guides | 3 |
| Help and onboarding published | Setup or migration guidance | 3 |
| Independent reviews | Rating from a source that permits display | 10 |
Payroll
| Component | Item | Points |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing published | Price in rand on the vendor site | 5 |
| Pricing published | Plan limits stated | 5 |
| Pricing published | Add-on prices stated | 5 |
| Pricing published | VAT treatment of prices stated | 5 |
| Pricing published | Trial or free-tier terms stated | 5 |
| South African compliance support published | EMP201 support | 5 |
| South African compliance support published | EMP501 support | 4 |
| South African compliance support published | UIF declaration support | 3 |
| South African compliance support published | IRP5 certificate support | 3 |
| South African compliance support published | POPIA or data-protection statement | 5 |
| South African compliance support published | Data storage location stated | 5 |
| Bank feeds and integrations published | Public integrations directory | 15 |
| Terms published | Cancellation terms and notice period | 4 |
| Terms published | Data export on exit described | 4 |
| Terms published | Price-change notice period | 3 |
| Terms published | Support channels and hours | 4 |
| Help and onboarding published | Public help centre | 4 |
| Help and onboarding published | South Africa-specific guides | 3 |
| Help and onboarding published | Setup or migration guidance | 3 |
| Independent reviews | Rating from a source that permits display | 10 |
Invoicing
| Component | Item | Points |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing published | Price in rand on the vendor site | 5 |
| Pricing published | Plan limits stated | 5 |
| Pricing published | Add-on prices stated | 5 |
| Pricing published | VAT treatment of prices stated | 5 |
| Pricing published | Trial or free-tier terms stated | 5 |
| South African compliance support published | South African tax invoice support | 10 |
| South African compliance support published | POPIA or data-protection statement | 8 |
| South African compliance support published | Data storage location stated | 7 |
| Bank feeds and integrations published | Public integrations directory | 15 |
| Terms published | Cancellation terms and notice period | 4 |
| Terms published | Data export on exit described | 4 |
| Terms published | Price-change notice period | 3 |
| Terms published | Support channels and hours | 4 |
| Help and onboarding published | Public help centre | 4 |
| Help and onboarding published | South Africa-specific guides | 3 |
| Help and onboarding published | Setup or migration guidance | 3 |
| Independent reviews | Rating from a source that permits display | 10 |
Bill and receipt capture
| Component | Item | Points |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing published | Price in rand on the vendor site | 5 |
| Pricing published | Plan limits stated | 5 |
| Pricing published | Add-on prices stated | 5 |
| Pricing published | VAT treatment of prices stated | 5 |
| Pricing published | Trial or free-tier terms stated | 5 |
| South African compliance support published | POPIA or data-protection statement | 13 |
| South African compliance support published | Data storage location stated | 12 |
| Bank feeds and integrations published | Public integrations directory | 15 |
| Terms published | Cancellation terms and notice period | 4 |
| Terms published | Data export on exit described | 4 |
| Terms published | Price-change notice period | 3 |
| Terms published | Support channels and hours | 4 |
| Help and onboarding published | Public help centre | 4 |
| Help and onboarding published | South Africa-specific guides | 3 |
| Help and onboarding published | Setup or migration guidance | 3 |
| Independent reviews | Rating from a source that permits display | 10 |
How are price tiers set?
A product's tier is computed from its lowest published paid monthly price including VAT. No vendor declares its own tier and neither do we.
| Tier | Lowest paid plan per month incl. VAT |
|---|---|
| Entry | Up to R300 |
| Core | R301 to R900 |
| Advanced | Over R900 |
What is the owner's assessment?
Where the site's owner has tested a product, the record adds her dated assessment in five bands: setup effort, month-end fit, VAT and payroll in practice, reporting, and support. It is written only by her. On tested products a full score combines 60% Record Score and 40% assessment, and is always shown beside the Record Score.
How are reviews handled?
Review ratings are shown only from a source whose terms allow display. Until one is confirmed, the reviews item is pending for every product.